In today’s construction industry, blast furnace slag has emerged as a game-changer, offering a sustainable alternative to traditional cement while enhancing concrete properties. The adoption of a by-product of steel that was once considered as waste material is now transforming construction by enhancing concrete’s properties.
This revolutionary material reduces the environmental impact of concrete production and imparts special properties that make concrete more durable and resistant to various forms of degradation, extending the service life of structures built in harsh environmental conditions. Let’s explore this remarkable material and its impact on the concrete industry.
What is Blast Furnace Slag?
Blast furnace slag is a byproduct of iron production in blast furnaces. It’s primarily composed of calcium oxide (CaO), silica (SiO2), alumina (Al2O3), and magnesium oxide (MgO). The exact composition varies depending on the raw materials used in iron production, but these four oxides typically make up the majority of the slag.
Blast furnace slag, Courtesy of photos: Wikimedia
In the process of making iron in a blast furnace, iron ore is combined with coke (a form of carbon) and fluxing agents such as limestone. This results in the separation of molten iron from slag, a glassy, non-metallic material that floats on top of the molten iron.
The slag is then rapidly cooled with water, creating granulated blast-furnace slag (GBFS), which can be ground into a fine powder and used as a supplementary cementitious material (SCM).
Depending on the method of cooling, Blast furnace slag creates other forms of the material, such as air-cooled slag, which is commonly used as construction material.
The Historical Journey of Blast Furnace Slag
The utilization of blast furnace slag in construction dates back approximately 2,000 years to the Roman Empire. During this period, broken slag from crude iron-making forges was incorporated into road base construction, demonstrating an early recognition of its structural value.
In Germany, blast furnace slag has been used in construction since the 1860s. However, it wasn’t until the 20th century that its potential as a cement replacement was fully realized. As environmental concerns grew in the late 20th and early 21st centuries, blast furnace slag gained prominence as a sustainable alternative in concrete production.
Oldest Roman road in Italia, Courtesy of photos: Wikipedia,
Despite this early application, the systematic use of slag remained sporadic for centuries. The material’s journey from occasional use to widespread adoption has been gradual, with significant advancements occurring primarily during the Industrial Revolution and subsequent periods of rapid infrastructure development.
Throughout much of history, slag was erroneously classified as a mere industrial waste product, with its true potential as a versatile construction material going largely unrecognized.
The understanding and appreciation of blast furnace slag have accelerated in recent decades as sustainability concerns have prompted the search for alternatives to traditional cement.
The advancements in materials science and a deeper understanding of concrete chemistry have elevated the modern scientific understanding of the material. As researchers began to investigate the properties of slag more thoroughly, they discovered that its composition and behavior made it an excellent candidate for partial cement replacement.
Understanding Blast Furnace Slag: Composition and Nature
Blast furnace slag is defined as “the non-metallic product consisting essentially of silicates and alumino-silicates of calcium and other bases that is developed in a molten condition simultaneously with iron in a blast furnace”.
The primary components of blast furnace slag are limestone (CaO) at approximately 41.7%, silica (SiO2) at around 33.8%, and alumina (Al2O3) at roughly 13.4%, with additional components including magnesium oxide (MgO) at about 7.4% and small amounts of sulfur.
This chemical composition bears a similarity to that of ordinary Portland cement, which explains its compatibility as a cement replacement material in concrete applications. The complex chemical nature of blast-furnace slag enables it to participate in cementitious reactions when properly processed and activated.
The physical characteristics of blast furnace slag depend significantly on how it is processed after leaving the blast furnace. Typically, blast furnace slag appears as a gray vesicular material that is lighter than most basalt. It possesses pozzolanic properties with some self-cementing characteristics, which become more pronounced as the fineness of the material increases.
The spherical shape characteristic of GGBS contributes to improved workability in concrete mixtures containing blast-furnace slag. The material’s physical structure also influences its reactivity and behavior in concrete, with finer particles generally demonstrating greater reactivity due to increased surface area.
During iron production, the blast furnace is charged with iron ore, limestone, and coke. As these materials melt, the slag floats on top of the molten iron and is separated. The cooling method determines the final product and its crystalline, glassy, vesicular, or cellular properties.
- Air-cooled blast-furnace slag (ACBFS): Slowly cooled in pits, resulting in a crystalline and vesicular structure. Dense and hard material suitable for construction
- Granulated blast-furnace slag: Rapidly cooled with water jets, creating a glassy, sand-like material. Ground and used as a replacement for cement
- Pelletized slag: spherical and high glassy pellets, cooled and solidified using air and water in a spinning drum.
- Expanded BF slag: treatment of liquid slag with controlled quantities of water, which is less than that required for granulation. More vesicular and cellular
The Production Process: From Iron Making to Construction Material
The production of blast furnace slag is intrinsically linked to the iron manufacturing process. Within integrated steelworks, iron production begins by charging blast furnaces with iron ore, coke as fuel, and limestone as a fluxing agent4.
Iron smelting process, Courtesy of photos: Wikimedia
This process operates continuously, with raw materials gradually settling as iron is melted from the ore in a reducing atmosphere, creating a molten pool at approximately 1600°C at the bottom of the furnace. As the iron is reduced and coke is consumed for energy, slag forms, comprising lime from the limestone and silicates and aluminates from the iron ore and coke.
Due to its lower density, the slag floats on top of the molten iron, allowing both materials to be periodically tapped from the furnace. For each tonne of iron produced, approximately 300kg of slag is generated, representing a substantial volume of material that can be repurposed rather than discarded.
After separation from the heavier iron, the liquid slag undergoes further processing that determines its final properties and applications. The most common processing methods include granulation with water or air cooling.
The granulation process involves rapid cooling of the molten slag with large amounts of water, which gives the slag both a granulated and amorphous (glassy) structure. This rapid cooling process is crucial for developing the hydraulic properties that make blast-furnace slag valuable for cement applications.
The resulting granulated blast-furnace slag is then typically ground to produce Ground Granulated blast-furnace slag (GGBS), which possesses cementitious properties that enable it to partially replace Portland cement in concrete mixes.
Production of Blast Furnace Slag Cement Mix
Blast furnace slag is also blended with clinker in cement production to produce a portland blast furnace slag cement. In cement production, blast furnace slag cement is produced containing varying proportions of slag – Type A with 5-30% slag content, Type B with 30-60%, and Type C with 60-70%.
The production of blast furnace slag cement mix involves:
- Grinding cement clinker and granulated blast-furnace slag separately.
- Wet milling the slag in an attrition mill.
- Drying the slag slurry.
- Mixing the components: attrition-milled slag, ball-milled clinker, and gypsum (1-5%).
The final product typically contains granulated blast-furnace slag, Portland cement clinker, and 1-5% gypsum.
How Does Blast Furnace Slag Concrete Work?
Blast furnace slag is typically used as a partial replacement for cement in concrete, though in some cases, it can replace 100% of the cement. When BFS is mixed with water and other materials, it undergoes a chemical reaction that is very similar to the hydration process of Portland cement. However, BFS does not have inherent cementitious properties unless it is activated, usually by the addition of an alkaline substance (such as lime or cement).
Hydration Process of Blast Furnace Slag
1. Primary Activation: In slag concrete, Portland cement acts as the activator, initiating the hydration process. Portland cement contains calcium silicates that react with water to produce calcium silicate hydrate (C-S-H), which is responsible for the strength and durability of concrete.
2. Reaction with Blast Furnace Slag: The BFS, when exposed to the alkaline environment provided by cement, reacts slowly over time to form additional C-S-H. This improves the density and microstructure of the concrete, leading to enhanced long-term strength and durability.
3. Pozzolanic Reaction: BFS also has pozzolanic properties, which means it can react with calcium hydroxide (a byproduct of the hydration of Portland cement) to form additional C-S-H. This reaction not only improves the concrete’s strength but also helps in reducing porosity and permeability.
Sustainability and Green Concrete
Blast furnace slag is considered a green alternative in concrete production for several reasons:
- It reduces clinker usage in cement production.
- It lowers greenhouse gas emissions.
- It decreases energy consumption in concrete production.
- It utilizes industrial waste, reducing environmental pollution.
Portland blast furnace slag cement (PBFSC) emits about 40% less CO2 than traditional Portland cement, making it an eco-friendly option.
Applications and Uses of Blast Furnace Slag Cement
The versatility of BFS concrete allows it to be used in a wide range of applications, including:
1. Marine Structures: Due to its resistance to chloride penetration, BFS concrete is commonly used in the construction of ports, seawalls, and other marine infrastructure.
2. Bridges and Highways: BFS concrete’s long-term durability and resistance to environmental stressors make it ideal for bridge decks, piers, and highways.
3. Mass Concrete Structures: The lower heat of hydration of BFS makes it suitable for mass concrete applications such as dams and foundations, where excessive heat buildup can cause cracking.
4. Precast Concrete Products: BFS is frequently used in precast concrete products, such as pipes, slabs, and panels, to improve performance.
5. Industrial Flooring: BFS concrete’s resistance to chemical attack makes it ideal for industrial flooring in factories, warehouses, and chemical plants.
6. Road construction: an application that dates back to Roman times. The material serves effectively in road base layers, providing structural stability while offering environmental advantages compared to conventional materials.
7. Ground improvement: Ground improver and surface layer stabilizer, as well as a middle and deep-layer soil improver in geotechnical applications.
8. Specialty applications such as grout additives, inorganic grout materials, injected materials, and fillers.
As construction material, blast-furnace slag finds applications in various construction projects:
- As an aggregate in road pavement applications.
- In the production of Portland blast furnace slag cement.
- As a concrete aggregate, it is used to replace natural aggregates.
- As GGBFS, partially replacing Portland cement in concrete mixtures.
- Filter Aggregate
- Construction fill and selected fill
- Scour protection
- Rockwool.
Blast Furnace Slag Replacement Ratios of Cement
Mixing blast-furnace slag with cement to make concrete involves carefully selecting the appropriate replacement ratio and following proper mixing procedures. Here’s a guide on how to mix slag furnace with cement for concrete production:
The optimal replacement ratio of cement with blast-furnace slag varies depending on the application and desired properties:
- General use: 25-50%13
- Sulfate resistance (Type II equivalence): 25-50%3
- Sulfate resistance (Type V equivalence): 50-65%3
- Mass concrete: 50-80%3
- Optimum strength development: 40-50%3
- Arkansas DOT approved: Up to 40%3
Source:https://www.skywaycement.com
Concrete Mixing Procedure
- Prepare materials: Gather Portland cement, ground granulated blast-furnace slag (GGBFS), aggregates, and water.
- Determine mix design: Based on the desired concrete properties and application, select the appropriate replacement ratio of GGBFS to cement.
- Weigh materials: Accurately measure the required quantities of cement, GGBFS, aggregates, and water according to the mix design.
- Dry mix: Combine the dry ingredients (cement, GGBFS, and aggregates) in the mixer before adding water.
- Add water: Gradually add water to the dry mix while the mixer is running.
- Mix thoroughly: Continue mixing until the concrete achieves a uniform consistency and desired workability.
- Perform quality control tests: Check the fresh concrete properties such as slump, air content, and temperature to ensure they meet specifications.
Step-by-step guide for mix proportioning of blast furnace slag with cement according to ACI 211:
- Determine the required average compressive strength (fcr′) based on the specified strength (fc′) and standard deviation of test results.
- Select the water-to-cementitious materials ratio (w/cm) based on the required strength and exposure conditions.
- Choose the total cementitious materials content based on the w/cm ratio and required workability.
- Determine the slag cement replacement percentage:
- Calculate the quantities of portland cement and slag cement based on the total cementitious materials content and replacement percentage1.
- Estimate the mixing water content based on the desired slump, maximum aggregate size, and air content.
- Select the coarse aggregate content based on the maximum size and fineness modulus of the fine aggregate.
- Calculate the fine aggregate content by subtracting the volumes of cement, slag, water, coarse aggregate, and air from the unit volume of concrete.
- Adjust the mix proportions based on the specific gravity of slag cement (2.85 to 2.94) compared to portland cement (3.15).
- Perform trial batches to verify concrete properties and make necessary adjustments.
- Consider reducing water demand by up to 5% for a given slump when using slag cement.
- If using chemical admixtures, determine proper dosages through trial batches.
Remember that slag cement is compatible with other supplementary cementitious materials like fly ash and silica fume, allowing for ternary blends. Always consult local specifications and perform trial batches to ensure the concrete meets project requirements.
Benefits of Using Blast Furnace Slag in Concrete
The use of BFS in concrete has multiple benefits, both technical and environmental.
1. Improved Durability
– Enhanced Sulfate Resistance: BFS improves the resistance of concrete to sulfate attack, making it ideal for structures exposed to aggressive environments such as wastewater treatment plants or marine structures, industrial settings, and infrastructure exposed to de-icing salts or groundwater with high mineral content.
– Reduced Chloride Permeability: BFS concrete shows lower permeability to chloride ions, reducing the risk of steel reinforcement corrosion in structures like bridges and buildings.
– Improved Freeze-Thaw Resistance: Concrete with BFS has a denser microstructure, which improves its resistance to freeze-thaw cycles.
-Improved durability translates to extended service life for structures built with slag-containing concrete, reducing lifecycle costs and resource consumption associated with repairs and replacements.
2. Higher long-term strength
While early-age strength development may be slower with higher slag content, the long-term strength of slag-containing concrete often exceeds that of conventional Portland cement concrete, particularly in applications where thermal stress mitigation is important
3. Environmental Sustainability
– Reduced Carbon Footprint: The production of Portland cement is highly energy-intensive and emits a significant amount of CO2. By replacing a portion of cement with BFS, the overall carbon footprint of concrete can be significantly reduced. The manufacture of GGBS requires less than one-fifth the energy needed for Portland cement production and generates less than one-fifteenth of the carbon dioxide emissions.
– Waste Utilization: Using BFS in concrete helps divert industrial waste from landfills, promoting more sustainable construction practices.
4. Improved Workability
– BFS concrete is typically more workable than traditional concrete, making it easier to place, spread, and finish. This is particularly beneficial for large-scale construction projects.
5. Cost Savings
– Blast furnace slag is often more affordable than Portland cement, especially in regions close to steel manufacturing plants. Using BFS can reduce the cost of concrete production.
6. Higher Long-Term Strength
– While BFS concrete may gain strength at a slower rate in the early stages, it often outperforms traditional concrete in terms of long-term compressive strength. This makes it ideal for structures that need to last for several decades.
7. Enhanced Water tightness
This represents another significant advantage of blast-furnace slag concrete, with the material creating a denser microstructure that reduces permeability and enhances resistance to water penetration. This characteristic improves freeze-thaw durability and reduces the risk of reinforcement corrosion in steel-reinforced concrete structures.
8. Inhibits alkali aggregate
Blast furnace slags inhibit Alkali aggregate reactions that can cause destructive expansion in conventional concrete.
9-Lowers heat of hydration
Reduces cracking through exothermic suppression, moderating the heat generated during cement hydration and thereby minimizing thermal gradients that can lead to early-age cracking6.
Challenges of Using Blast Furnace Slag in Concrete
Despite its many advantages, BFS concrete does come with a few challenges:
1. Slower Strength Gain: BFS concrete may gain strength more slowly, especially in cooler conditions. This can be a concern for projects with tight construction timelines, with research indicating that over a 28-day duration, slag-containing concrete typically develops only about 80% of the strength achieved by conventional Portland cement concrete during the same period.
This slower strength gain results from the lower heat of hydration and delayed reaction kinetics associated with slag cement, particularly at higher replacement levels. Concrete with blast-furnace slag sets more slowly than traditional concrete, which may affect construction schedules.
-Slag concrete requires longer curing periods to achieve optimal strength. The hydration rate of slag is affected by environmental temperature and humidity.
-The most significant challenge relates to early strength development. For applications requiring rapid strength development, such as fast-track construction, precast concrete manufacturing, or cold-weather concreting, this limitation may necessitate either reduced slag content or the use of activators to accelerate reaction rates.
Engineers and concrete producers must carefully balance the long-term performance benefits against these early-age considerations when designing concrete mixtures for specific applications.
2. Availability: The availability of BFS can be limited in regions without steel production facilities, which may increase transportation costs. The properties of the material can vary significantly depending on the source and processing methods.
This variability can complicate quality control efforts and may require more rigorous testing and mix design adjustments to ensure consistent performance
3. Incompatibility with Certain Admixtures: Some chemical admixtures used in concrete may not perform as effectively in BFS concrete. Proper testing and mix design adjustments are essential.
Future Prospects: The Evolving Role of Blast Furnace Slag in Construction
The future of blast furnace slag in construction appears promising as the industry increasingly prioritizes sustainability alongside performance. Ongoing research continues to expand our understanding of the material’s behavior in various applications, enabling more optimized usage and broader adoption.
Advances in slag processing technologies are enhancing the consistency and reactivity of the material, addressing some of the historical limitations while maximizing performance benefits. Additionally, the development of new activation methods and admixtures specifically designed for slag-containing mixtures is improving early-age performance while preserving long-term advantages.
These technological advancements, coupled with growing environmental awareness and stricter regulations regarding carbon emissions, position blast furnace slag as an increasingly important component in the construction industry’s sustainability strategy.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
1. What percentage of cement can be replaced by blast-furnace slag?
The percentage of BFS replacement can vary depending on the specific requirements of the project. Typically, 30-50% of the Portland cement is replaced with BFS, but in some cases, BFS can replace up to 70% or more.
2. Does blast-furnace slag concrete take longer to set?
Yes, BFS concrete may have a slightly slower setting time compared to traditional concrete. However, this slower setting time can be advantageous in hot climates as it helps reduce the risk of early-age cracking.
3. Is blast-furnace slag concrete more expensive than regular concrete?
While the price of BFS can vary, it is often more cost-effective than Portland cement. Additionally, using BFS can result in long-term savings due to its improved durability and reduced maintenance requirements.
4. Can blast furnace slag concrete be used in cold weather?
BFS concrete can be used in cold weather conditions, but precautions may need to be taken. The slower hydration rate of BFS means that it may take longer for the concrete to gain strength in colder temperatures. Using accelerators or adjusting the mix design can help mitigate this issue.
5. Is blast-furnace slag concrete sustainable?
Yes, using BFS in concrete helps reduce the carbon footprint associated with cement production and repurposes an industrial byproduct that would otherwise go to waste. This makes it a more environmentally friendly option than traditional concrete.
6. How does blast furnace slag affect the color of concrete?
Concrete containing BFS tends to have a lighter, more uniform color compared to traditional Portland cement concrete. This can be an aesthetic advantage in certain architectural applications.
Conclusion
Blast furnace slag has revolutionized the concrete industry, offering a sustainable solution that enhances concrete properties. As we continue to seek environmentally friendly building materials, blast furnace slag stands out as a prime example of turning industrial waste into a valuable resource. While it does have some limitations, the benefits far outweigh the drawbacks, making it an excellent choice for modern construction projects. As research continues and technology advances, we can expect blast furnace slag to play an increasingly important role in the future of sustainable construction.
Sources:
1. Poon, C.S., Kou, S.C., & Lam, L. (2002). **Use of recycled aggregates in molded concrete bricks and blocks**. *Construction and Building Materials*, 16(5), 281-289.
2. Siddique, R., & Klaus, J. (2009). **Influence of ground granulated blast furnace slag on the properties of concrete: A review**. *Journal of Civil Engineering and Management*, 15(3), 203-214.
3. American Concrete Institute. (2014). **Slag Cement in Concrete and Mortar** (ACI 233R-03). ACI.
4. Neville, A.M. (2011). **Properties of Concrete** (5th ed.). Pearson.
5. Malhotra, V.M., & Mehta, P.K. (2005). **High-Performance, High-Volume Fly Ash Concrete: Materials, Mixture Proportioning, Properties, Construction Practice, and Case Histories**. Supplementary Cementitious Materials for Sustainable Development.
6. https://www.cement-plants.com/applications/slag-cement-manufacturing-process/
7. https://www.ispatguru.com/blast-furnace-slag/
8. https://www.slg.jp/e/slag/character.html
9. https://www.asa-inc.org.au/products/blast-furnace-slag
10. https://ukcsma.co.uk/sustainability/